| 2006 All-Bianchi |
| Ali Reslan–2nd Team Defense |
| David Twamley–2nd Team Midfield |
| Connor Farrell–2nd Team Midfield |
| 2007 All-Bianchi |
| David Twamley–1st Team Midfield |
| Carlo Ingato–2nd Team Attack |
| Connor Farrell–2nd Team Midfield |
| 2008 All-State |
| David Twamley–2nd Team Midfield |
| 2008 All-Bianchi |
| David Twamley–1st Team Midfield |
| Mike Efstatios–1st Team Attack |
| Carlo Ingato–2nd Team Attack |
| 2009 All-State |
| David Twamley–1st Team Midfield |
| Eric Valero–1st Team Attack |
| Henry MacQueen–2nd Team Defense |
| 2009 Academic All-American |
| Connor Farrell |
| 2009 All-CVC |
| David Twamley–CVC Player of the Year |
| Eric Valero–1st Team Attack |
| David Twamley–1st Team Midfield |
| Connor Farrell-1st Team Midfield |
| Henry MacQueen–1st Team Defense |
| Evan Burke–1st Team Goalie |
| Alex Rohrbach–2nd Team Attack |
| Andrew Nieffer–2nd Team Defense |
| 2010 All-CVC |
| Alex Rohrbach–1st Team Attack |
| Henry MacQueen–1st Team Defense |
| Bijan Matthews–2nd Team Midfield |
| Chris Matthews–2nd Team Defense |
| 2010 All-State |
| Henry MacQueen–Honorable Mention |
| Alex Rohrbach–Honorable Mention |
| 2010 Academic All-American |
| Henry MacQueen |
| 2011 All-CVC |
| Alex Rohrbach–CVC Player of the Year |
| Alex Rorhbach–1st Team Attack |
| Marty Flately–1st Team Defense |
| Chris Clancey–2nd Team Attack |
| Bijan Matthews–2nd Team Midfield |
| Austin Gioseffi–2nd Team Defense |
| 2011 US Lacrosse All-American |
| Alex Rorhbach |
